reviews on Michael Ninn's Catherine

www.avn.com

Catherine
Reviewed by Mark Kernes
Published in AVN October 2005

Content Rating: AAAAA

Review: Michael Ninn shatters time and space to deliver the story of history's most sexual monarch (or is it?), assaulting the senses with sound and imagery whose sole purpose is to Turn You On - and son of a gun if he hasn't produced Art at the same time!

Audrey Hollander is amazing as a woman being driven crazy by boyfriend Otto Bauer - so much that she retreats into the white-faced persona of Russian monarch Catherine the Great, imagining herself having anal sex (reverse cowgirl/horsie/doggie) on the snow-covered steps of massive buildings, helping handmaidens get it on with a strap-on in the public square, and taking two cocks up her ass and one in her mouth in the fire-lit great hall of her mansion.

But simple descriptions can hardly convey the grandeur of the artistic accomplishment here. Ninn has often been criticized for shooting lackluster sex in beautiful scenery, but this part-film/part-video creation is as hot as anything on the market today.

In the annals of adult video history, Catherine will be long remembered as an example of the heights that can be reached with a real director at the helm.

Easy pre-noms for both of Audrey's anal scenes. And let's not forget pre-noms for Best Director, Best Video-Cinematography(?), Best Art Direction, Best Editing, Best Special Effects (you won't believe what isn't real), Best Music and Best Film/Video (we may have to invent a new category).

Retailing: Ninn's best work to date, so encourage all customers to check it out!

DVD Extras: Behind the Scenes Featurettes, Bonus Scenes, Interviews, Still Galleries, Trailers

www.rogreviews.com

STARS: Audrey Hollander, Nikki Blond, Victoria Swinger, Adriana Rouso, Valentina Velasques, Otto Bauer, Mike Foster, Bruno Sx,

REVIEW-

Making revolutionary porn is nothing new to Michael Ninn. He has been re-writing the rule book for well over a decade and could probably fill a swimming pool with all of the awards he has collected in that time. Rather than re-hash what he’s done in the past fifteen years let’s focus on Ninn’s recent moves toward high class productions (Which he always gave us) that feature spectacular sex scenes. His two Neo Pornographia movies were incredible sexually and seem to lead us right in to what he’s got with Catherine. Audrey Hollander plays the lead in this project and looks amazing in full make up. We already know that she can bring incredible heat to her sex scenes so this would seem to be a perfect combination of technical brilliance, eye candy and sexual heat.

Audrey Hollander and Otto Bauer play the leads in this epic. As the movie opens with Catherine on snow covered steps being chastised by Otto. His accusations have to do with her wicked fantasies and she does nothing at all to dissuade him. She spreads her legs and gets her fingers working between her pale thighs. Her tight little ass takes four fingers as he really works her over. She wraps her bright red lips around his cock and even the glossy look and echo-chamber sound can’t slow down the rough throat fucking he gives her. The brutality is well covered, but we don’t really get a chance to see how beautiful Audrey is and how well she can suck cock. Moving quickly to anal, Otto bends her over and takes control of that ass. (Though come on, after four fingers his dick isn’t exactly going to do a lot of damage.) He finishes her off with a hot on the face.

Images bombard us for several minutes as present-day Audrey is haunted by visions from the past. She and Otto watch as Bruno Sx punishes a “whore” played by Valentina Velasques. He spits on her pussy and slaps her thighs. With Audrey there to help, they force her head down around his cock. The brutality leads into a hard sex scene that is beautifully shot. We have become somewhat accustomed to this odd mix of nasty action with exceptional quality thanks to Ninn’s recent work, but it is still a rare experience. The RCA is outstanding and the more he slaps her clit, the harder Valentina fucks him back. There is some really good anal action here as Valentina gets what she “deserves” right up to a big shot on her face.

Audrey’s odd odyssey continues as she teams with Nikki Blonde and Adriana Rouso for a really outstanding three-way. The girls play with each other, but break out a big black strap on when Audrey gets pulled into the mix. They fuck her tight ass with long hard strokes. In a movie this good I am shocked to find that I really just want the lesbian action to continue.

As the dreams (or fantasies) continue things get lighter. Beautiful Victoria Swinger lifts her heavy dress and gives Mike Foster access to what she has hidden underneath. There is some beautifully lit footage as she works her pretty lips up and down his hard cock. The sex here is not as rough as most of what we have seen so far, but it isn’t soft either. It’s a solid scene with some great cowgirl as she bounces to take every inch of his dick. I love the way this scene looks and the mix between eye candy and heat is perfect.

The climactic scene features Otto punishing Audrey for her sins. He brings in Bruno and Mike to do the deed. They give her some very rough oral sex, shoving her head back and forth and trying to split her head open with their hard rods. Moving right from blowjobs to DP, they slam her as hard as they can while Otto hovers around berating her verbally. The creepy factor is so high that it almost distracts us from the great action. With three guys now around her Audrey gets plugged n every hole, double stuffed in the ass and finally covered in hot sticky cream.

Michael Ninn has written the latest chapter in his epic porn career with an amazing effort. Catherine picks up sexually where he left off with the two Neo Pornographia projects. He has taken things a step toward a fully scripted feature with blistering sex. I wouldn’t say we actually have a story or a plot here, but there is more going on than just scenes blending together. This movie is a barrage of images that create a surreal dream that sometimes borders on the nightmarish. Rather than drive a story with dialog, Ninn assaults us with the visual. Audrey Hollander is perfectly cast in the lead for this project. She looks amazing in the make up and wardrobe, but more importantly she brings amazing heat to the sex scenes. During the rough scenes Audrey shows everyone why she is such a popular gonzo girl. Not only can she take the action, but she can dish it out as well. This performance should solidify her as a finalist for every performer of the year award they can give out. Though I still root for fully scripted features with hot sex and although much of the sex here really isn’t what I’m looking for (Double anal, gagging, yawn) it is clear that this is one of the best-made features of the year. If you want to see the frontrunner for just about every major award this year, look no further than “Catherine.”

adult.dvdempire.com

In-House Review To view our reviews section click here

Ninn Dives Into The Surreal With The Exceptional Catherine
5.00 out of 5.00 - Film: 5 Features: 5 Video: 5 Audio: 5 - 9/22/2005


Catherine is one of the big adult releases for the fall of 2005, and one can only hope that its surreal, but spectacular, vision doesn’t get lost in the hype of other, less original, adult features starring more recognizable talent.

The movie, directed by Michael Ninn, contains some of the more impressive and memorable visuals I have seen in an adult movie...yet it also contains one of the more incomprehensible storylines – so one wonders how appealing Ninn’s vision will be to the porn masses out there.

Catherine stars sexy redhead Audrey Hollander in the title role...a woman living in the present who must fight off the demons going on inside her head (represented by visions that seem to take place in the past) before she is driven to do something terrible. Is she suffering from multiple personality disorder? Is she remembering a past life? Is this reviewer totally off-base on his interpretation of Ninn’s work? Who’s to say? Part of Catherine’s appeal is that much is left up to the mind of the viewer – which will likely lead to different viewers drawing different conclusions...which may be exactly what Ninn’s intentions are with his film.

All of this is shown in glorious anamorphic widescreen and 2.0 Dolby sound...giving the viewer both a great-looking picture (although Ninn plays with his images – often slightly blurring or over-saturating the picture to give the movie a more dreamlike quality) and making the soundtrack all the more haunting and encompassing to the home viewer.

As for the sex, there are five scenes in Catherine all of which take place “inside the mind” of the lead character...at least according to my assessment of what is happening in the movie. First up is a scene between Audrey and Otto Bauer (who also plays her boyfriend in the present). Even though Ninn has directed a number of couples-friendly adult titles in the past years, he allows Audrey and Otto to do what they do best on camera – namely aggressive and slightly vulgar sex with lots of anal play included.

Scene Two takes place inside a castle and has dark-haired Valentina Velasquez being ravished by a bald Bruno Sx, with Audrey encouraging him on and occasionally rubbing Valentina’s pussy. There’s a hot lesbian three-way at the mid-point of the movie, during which Audrey joins Nikki Blond and Adriana Rouso. The scene includes Nikki donning a strap-on and Audrey riding her cowgirl...including some cowgirl riding as Audrey has a butt plug lodged firmly in her ass.

The most couples-friendly scene in Catherine is a pairing between Victoria Swinger and Mike Foster, which takes place somewhere inside the castle (all these locations were actually shot in Budapest) and consists of reverse cowgirl, cowgirl, standing missionary and a scene-ending pop-shot into Victoria’s mouth.

The final scene is worth waiting for, as Audrey gets into a foursome with Bruno, Mike and Otto. Not only is there plenty of double penetration in this scene, but there’s some double anal penetration too, and great oral pop-shots at the conclusion.

The copy of Catherine I reviewed was a preview disc from the studio – which offered only a taste of the bonus features. The release will come with a second disc to hold all the extras, which will include a “Meet Otto & Audrey” featurette; a handful of photo galleries; a bonus scene between Audrey and Justine Joli; separate solo-masturbation bonus scenes with Nikki Blond and Adriana Rouso; and a Behind The Scenes featurette. As far as I know, no director’s commentary track is going to be a part of this release...which is a slight disappointment – if only to hear what Ninn’s vision and intention was for the more surreal parts of Catherine.

A lot of adult directors like to say their work is “artistic,” but Catherine is truly a movie that can stake a claim to that term. It’s not only one of the best DVDs of 2005, but it’s one of the best movies Michael Ninn has done in years.

- Adult DVD Empire
by Spooky

SILICON SLAVE


Reviewer: "Miss Trixx" (Read Bio)

Review Date: 9/26/2005
Noise: Gothic, choir like music fitting the Victoria era.
Aesthetics: Beautiful wardrobe, period settings, and brilliant cinematography.

Michael Ninn has put together a very surreal and compelling film with Catherine. Starring Audrey Hollander as a present day woman haunted by a Victorian era woman with unquenchable carnal lusts, Catherine takes its audience on a spell binding tour of gothic settings and amazing cinematography. Catherine features lots of cutting between present day and the Victorian era with tasteful camera tricks that elevate this film far beyond gonzo flicks or other story based porn.

The film is set in winter in what appears to be an old stone manor with plenty of stone steps, columns, arched windows, and statues. The first scene starts with Catherine’s lord in a long coat with gold patterned embroidery circling her on stone steps Catherine is wearing a black mesh hair piece, black heels, and white make-up. Catherine starts the scene with some masturbation and soon receives some oral stimulation by her lord. Soon the lord has his hand up Catherine’s ass and then feeds her a little ass to mouth. Catherine returns the favor with a blow job and then hops on for some anal reverse cowboy action. This is followed up by some anal doggie style near a pillar featuring some ATM. The scene ends with a tame facial (which is recurrent throughout the film).


The action moves inside into a large dark gothic room with arched windows with grates, stone floors, stone walls, and a fire place. An audience is gathered, that includes Catherine. Catherine watches as a minion plays with a dark haired lady. The bald headed minion is wearing a long coat (something out of Hellraiser) with metal clasps in front while the lady is wearing a black short dress. He starts with some rough oral that includes some slapping, spitting, and quick entry with fingers. The lady then gives the minion a blow job as Catherine encourages them. Penetration starts with some doggie style followed by anal reverse cowboy. The scene ends with a blow job and another tame facial.


Flashes of three women with one in bondage with a mouth-piece halter are the precursor to scene three. A blond on stone steps with Catherine looking on from a balcony kicks off the action as she starts to masturbate. There are some beautiful stone statues in the corner of what appears to be a courtyard to add ambience to the action. The blond is wearing a burgundy embroidered coat with a burgundy mini skirt and is soon accompanied by another blond wearing a black silk top and silver mini skirt. They are both wearing long thigh high vinyl boots that I would love to add to my collection and any Dom would be proud to wear. Catherine wearing a lavender corset and long skirt soon comes down from her balcony to join the action. One of the blonds puts on a large black strap on that Catherine immediately blows while the other blond plunges her head up and down. Catherine takes it doggie style anally while she gives the other blond oral. Catherine goes cowboy style on the strap-on with the addition of Phallix glass butt plug and head halter. The blonds urge Catherine on with a riding crop and a strap.


A beautiful blond in a long white embroidered dress is sitting on an antique chair in gothic hallway complete with gargoyles. She is soon joined by a stud who gives her oral. She follows up with a blow job and then onto reverse cowboy and cowboy chair play. This scene wraps up fairly quickly with a tame facial.


The final sex act of this film takes place on stone steps at night and features Catherine with a white night gown with embroidered sleeves and collar. There is an antique red chase with black silk sheets at the bottom of the steps. Two men with long dark coats and the lord enter the scene. After the lord berates her and told her she should have left, Catherine is cast into two blow jobs with the minions. Soon the oral action ends and the play moves to double penetration in reverse cowboy. Catherine tries to run away but is returned by the lord. The lord joins the action with some double anal penetration. Like the other scenes, it ends with Catherine receiving a tame facial.


Catherine can take the taunting of the lord no more and ends the film with a dramatic knifing of her master. Catherine employs a very ornate dagger that is present in both the Victorian era and her contemporary apartment. Not only does the lord get the shaft, but so does her boyfriend. Hopefully the haunting is over as it looks like some jail time is in Catherine’s future.


I liked this adult film in that it wasn’t just a mind numbing porno flick but was very much a classy piece of production with some BDSM thrown in. The settings were incredible as were the wardrobes. Michael Ninn certainly knows how to work his camera and had a clear vision of what he wanted to convey. I found that unlike most adult content, I didn’t fast forward from scene to scene but watched this from beginning to end. There was definitely variety in play and cast. If you are looking for a gonzo flick with extreme facials, this film is not for you. If you are looking for something that you can watch with your lover and explore a more dark erotic side then break out your charge card.

World Class Adult Reviews

Review:
This was a rather interesting flick and as to not upset the flow and feeling of the movie I think I'm just going to break down the sex. Honestly I think I would do this movie injustice by attempting to spell out what was going on in-between scenes. I do have to say, this was one hell of a beautifully shot flick... WOW!

Scene 1: Audrey Hollander and Otto Bauer
Themes: ATM, Deep Throat, Anal
Scene Rating: 8.5/10
Scene Breakdown: Audrey is a sexy looking girl with medium length red hair and fake C cup tits. this scene takes place outside and one some steps. We watch as she starts off playing with her pussy and eventually Otto enters the scene with her taking his fingers (4 of them) and showing them deep in side her and then upping the ante, she adds 4 more! Moving a little more south, Otto shifts his fingers to her asshole (yes all 4) as she begs him to fuck her. After having her taste her ass she slowly works his cock out to suck and deep throat, then Otto gives her what she needs as we cut to Audrey easing her ass down on his cock, riding it in reverse cowgirl (anal). We get some nice shots of the action too. Reaching around, Otto stuffs 4 fingers in her twat to start, then again cranking it up a notch, he stuffs the same 4 fingers in her ass along with his dick. Having enough, Otto pulls his hand away from the action, but evidently that's not what Audrey wanted because she re-stuffs her ass using her own 4 fingers! Cutting away we see her stand up with him behind her, fucking her ass in standing doggy as we catch some nice shots, then he picks her up for some form of flying reverse cowgirl. It doesn’t last too long and they get back to the "normal" action in standing doggy. Once more we have a cut, but this time Audrey's down in doggy getting her ass fucked with Otto stopping for her to do some ATM, then finally the scene comes to a close as he jerks off into Audrey's mouth; she pushes the cum out. This was a good scene, well shot and some interesting visuals. Nice energy too.

Scene 2: Valentina Velasques and Bruno Sx
Themes: Straight, Pussy Gaping, Anal, Ass Gaping
Scene Rating: 7.5/10
Scene Breakdown: Valentina is a pretty girl with long black hair and natural B cup tits. The scene begins as we see Valentina sitting on a couch as Bruno eats her out and fingers her, then we cut to him sitting as Audrey takes Valentina head and forced her to suck his cock. Audrey then moves down to Valentina's pussy, spanking it as she keeps on blowing Bruno. Moving on, we cut to Valentina in doggy with him fucking her while we get some nice shots and some nice pussy gapes, and she also looked as if she came pretty hard too. After that we cut and see her up in reverse cowgirl, first taking him vaginally but not for long as he slips in her ass with relative ease, immediately showing off some gapes too. Un-mounting she does some pseudo ATM action and then heads back up for reverse cowgirl with Bruno cycling between her ass and pussy as she rides this time, and once more she also looks to cum. Eventually the scene comes to an end as we cut to Valentina down on her knees as Bruno jerks off into her mouth; she pushes the cum out. Pretty good scene, but LOTS of shadows covering up the sex. I know it's a mood setting scene, but still....

Scene 3: Audrey Hollander, Adrianna Rouso and Nikki Blonde
Themes: Toys, Girl/Girl, Deep Throat, Anal
Scene Rating: 9/10
Scene Breakdown: Adrianna is a pretty girl with medium length blonde hair and fake D cup tits. Nikki is also a pretty girl with medium length brown hair, but has natural C cup tits. The scene begins as we see Nikki and Adrianna as they play with themselves, then we soon cut to them walking Audrey in. She has a horse type thing on her had as she's lead in. Cutting away we see Nikki lying on a couch with a strap-on attached to her as Adrianna gets Audrey out of her "get-up" and makes her suck the huge dick; Adrianna really forces her mouth on it too! Anyway, we cut and see Audrey up in doggy with her face buried in Adrianna’s pussy while Nikki fucks her ass and we get some nice shot of it too. Once more we have a cut and this time Adrianna has the strap-on on her with Audrey riding her in cowgirl while Nikki works a butt plug in and out of Audrey's ass. Soon after that the scene kind of ends as we cut to the girls all walking away.

Scene 4: Victoria Swinger and Mike Foster
Themes: Straight
Scene Rating: 8/10
Scene Breakdown: Victoria is a very pretty girl with long brown hair and natural B cup tits. The scene gets rolling as we see Victoria sitting in a chair as Mike eats and fingers her, then we cut to him sitting down as she gives back; blowing him. Moving on, she starts off riding in reverse cowgirl, taking a break for some PTM, and then gets back to RC. Afterwards we cut to Victoria riding Mike in cowgirl while we get some nice shots of the action, then he picks her up for some flying cowgirl action. After setting her down she does some PTM and then he jerks off into her mouth and she pushes the cum from her mouth. Although this was a good scene, it was a bit short.

Scene 5: Audrey Hollander, Bruno Sx, Mike Foster and Otto Bauer
Themes: Deep Throat, Anal, DP, Choking, ATM, Double Anal, Ass Gaping, Cum Swallowing
Scene Rating: 9/10
Scene Breakdown: The scene begins as we see Audrey down on her knees sucking Bruno's and Mike's cocks. Doing a very nice job on them with some nice deep throat action. Cutting away we see Audrey up in a reverse cowgirl DP with Otto choking and slapping her as she takes it, then Bruno takes a break from the action as she continues to ride in reverse cowgirl anal. Soon Bruno comes back in and fills her pussy back up, giving her more DP action while we get some nice shots of it. After un-mounting (well of sorts...), she does some ATM/PTM/deep throat on the guys, then goes up into cowgirl for more DP action for a bit. Cutting away Otto gets into the scene as he plays the anchor while Audrey up in cowgirl, taking it up the ass while Bruno and Mike take turns double stuffin' her ass while she does ATM on the guy not in her ass. The guys double stuff her ass and show off some gapes for a good bit and then we move back to the DP action. subsequently the scene ends with all three guys delivering an open mouth facial to her, which she plays with the cum before finally swallowing it down. This was a very good scene, subsequently looked like she got worked really well and looked like she loved every minute of it. Interesting although the snow looked fake (and I'm pretty sure it was) it still had to have been cold out, you could see steam rise off the cocks as Audrey sucked them - it was sexy too in an odd way...

Themes: ATM, Deep Throat, Anal, Straight Sex, Pussy Gaping, Ass Gaping, Toys, Girl/Girl, DP, Choking, Double Anal, Cum Swallowing

DVD Extras: The extras here were well, I don't know how they were! The copy of this movie I got was a "for screening purposes only" so I didn't get the second disc. There was however 11 minutes of teasers from the bonus disc on this disc. Normally I would add points for this on a title, but for now, I'm just going to add nothing as I haven’t seen the extras. I do hope to see those extras though, they look good! From the looks of it, there’s interview with Otto and Audrey, solo scenes from Nikki and Adriana, some regular behind the scenes and a bonus scene with Audrey and Justine!

Final Rating and Thoughts: This one gets a 9.00. Now I know it don't add up but I liked the movie outside of the sex so I added more points to put it where I thought it should be. The movie was spectacular as far as beauty and such, it was just so well shot and so neat to watch - the visuals were just amazing. Lots of mood setting and so forth. I'm not exactly sure WHAT the move was about, but I'm thinking it was more or less a decent into one woman's madness or maybe it was one big nightmare, but the flick defiantly had a surreal feel to it which added that much more to it. Although I'm going to put this down as a feature movie, I'm not totally sure it is, there's no real story but yet as I watched it I was pretty captivated and wanted to know what’s going to go on next. I can't recommend this one enough. I honestly think even the hardest of hardcore fans will dig this. As a side note, this would have been a 10 if I had the bonus material to rate as well. This is an easy recommended purchase, but I suggest getting the 2 DVD version for a few bucks more.


© World Class Adult Reviews (www.wcareviews.com)

Night Moves Magizane

Review:

CATHERINE - Ninn Worx DVD - This is definitely a true 5 star masterpeice of erotica. From the very haunting opening, through each mesmerizing scene, you travel back and forth in time. This exquisite production done in Budapest and L.A., is one of the best of 2005. It will elevate Audrey Hollander to star status and be a major pre nom for the AVN awards. Ninn has gone beyond his own limits with this erotic excursion destined to be a classic. Do not miss it! *****

Erotica by Clohi

The Review
I wanted to give you an early review of Michael Ninn’s biggest movie of the year, Catherine. Starring Audrey Hollander, Nikki Blond, Victoria Swinger, Adriana Rouso, Valentina Velasquez, Mike Foster, Bruno Sx and Otto Bauer. Catherine is directed by Michael Ninn.

This is Ninn story telling at it’s greatest. Just within the first five minutes of watching Catherine I was saying to myself I’ve never seen visuals like this in an adult movie before and that was only the beginning. You will see things in Catherine you never could imagine seeing in any movie, let alone in an adult movie.

Catherine is a story of a woman who is haunted by her sexual desires. They literally split her in two. On one hand there is a curious woman who loves her husband. On the other hand there is a wanton whore that demands to be set free. Her husband is played by Otto Bauer. Catherine is taken to dark places to see what her true desires are. Are they hers or are they some evil thing that is taking over her? You are taken to two different worlds. The Catherine that is fighting to stay alive is in a very modern world, clean, full of bright colors and light. The other side is dark and cold, full of heavy old architecture. It reminds me of Helsinki to be honest. The end is worthy of Hollywood. Audrey Hollander gives a performance that will not soon be forgotten. She literally is in almost every scene. Either acting or performing sexually. She will never look as beautiful as she does in this film. She wins AVN best actress right now without a doubt.

The sex is rough and sometimes down right violent. It all fits in the storyline of a woman in a desperate battle over her sexual self. The sex scenes with Audrey are extremely rough but that is how she likes it and I have yet to see any scene with her in it that isn’t rough. Her first scene is on the snowy steps of what looks to be an old European library. The scene has some extreme anal and ends with her eating his cum. I’m not going to give too much of the movie away. The sex plays so much into the story the details of the scenes would give away too much of the story. Have no worries. Once the movie is released I will post a full review with all the nasty details.

Catherine is for presale now. BUY IT! It’s the best artcore story telling I’ve ever seen. Combine that with sex that is out of this world and Michael Ninn is going to have to rent a truck to tote all the AVN awards he will win for Catherine. I am giving this a five out of five. If I had a higher score I would give it that. Look in a couple of weeks for an expanded review of Catherine once I get my hands on the two disc special edition.

Reviewed By: The Viking